War Post

BIDEN: Based on what you’ve said, there’s really no hope — we really should get the hell out of there right now. I mean, there’s nothing to do. Nothing.

ROSEN: As a journalist, I’m uncomfortable advising an imperialist power about how to be a more efficient imperialist power. And I don’t think that we’re there for the interest of the Iraqi people. I don’t think that’s ever been a motivation. […]

BIDEN: [If we withdraw], the good news is we wouldn’t be imperialists in Iraq, from your perspective.

ROSEN: Only elsewhere in the region. (laughter). … There’s no positive scenario in Iraq these days. Not every situation has a solution.

What a refreshing sight… speaking truth in front of Congress and cutting through the political fray on both sides to reveal the hollowness of any so-called exit strategy. Watch Nir Rosen here.

 

This small video blog operation equips Iraqis with cameras and other gear to go out and get the kinds of stories that foreign journalists can’t. An example of new media on a shoestring, as well as a better window into what, say, the Shatt al-Arab looks like on any given patrol day, or how crowded Basra’s streets were during last year’s Ramadan. One of their Iraqi videographers, 22 year-old Ali Shafeya Al-Moussawi, was killed this past December, underlining the ongoing risks for all reporters in Iraq as the five year anniversary of Operation Iraqi Freedom approaches.

 
Warner Plans to Investigate Pentagon’s Ban on YouTube, MySpace, Others

Reacting to the ban, soldiers said the real reason for the curbs were their negative comments about the war, including scepticism about George Bush’s claims about progress. Soldiers in the field and former soldiers, in blogs posted on sites such as Black Five, an unofficial site run by former paratrooper Matthew Burden, said the regulations would be inoperable with most troops obeying the rules but dissidents finding ways round the ban.

Mr Burden, editor of The Blog of War, a book pulling together accounts from the field, also criticised the decision: "No more military bloggers writing about their experiences in the combat zone. This is the best PR the military has - its most honest voice out of the war zone. And it’s being silenced."

More.  

 

Looking for the price of black market goods in Baghdad or a Slate-style daily round-up of Iraq’s newspapers? IraqSlogger has that and more, from a "Kirkuk Police Blotter" to categories about insurgents and journalists that are more substantitive than anything in the newspapers quoted on Slate. For example:

The Sunni fundamentalist website Islam Memo reports that joint U.S.-Iraqi forces are raiding civilian residences in Fallujah and breaking up TV sets of families who are caught watching the banned Zawraa TV satellite channel. At least one resident, Kamel Ahmed Hamadi, of Nazzal district in Fallujah, was detained. One person reportedly asked the raiding force in English about freedom of the press and as a result got a slap in the face by an American soldier, Nazzal district residents said.

"Safavids are Forbidden to Enter" was scrawled under a sign that reads "Welcome to Baghdad" at the Mahmudiya intersection, south of Baghdad, according to an Islam Memo correspondent. Safavid is a reference to the Persian Safavid Empire that invaded Iraq during the 16th and 17th centuries and massacred thousands of Sunnis. It is a derogatory term used by Sunni insurgents and fundamentalists to describe the Shia, their militias, and even Iraqi security forces. Two IEDs that were placed under the sign exploded when a police commando force attempted to wipe out the graffiti, killing and wounding several policemen.

The site went up recently and splits much of its content as "StateSde" anad "IraqiSide." Most of all, the latter includes an "Iraqi Diary;" the most recent post is from a woman in Baghdad writing about her 22 year-old cousin, a Sunni, who was killed because his fiance was Shia. To the question of why it also includes a "humor" link, the editors say they based the decision "in part because Iraqis and U.S. troops have a wickedly morbid sense of humor."

Graphic via Iraq Slogger.

Photos confirm US raid child deaths

"The relevance of Third Reich Germany to today’s America is not that Bush equals Hitler or that the United States government is a death machine. It’s that it provides a rather spectacular example of the insidious process by which decent people come to regard the unthinkable as not only thinkable but doable, justifiable. Of the way freethinkers and speakers become compliant and self-censoring. Of the mechanism by which moral or humanistic categories are converted into bureaucratic ones. And finally, of the willingness with which we hand control over to the state and convince ourselves that we are the masters of our destiny."

- Diane McHorter on Slate

A video showing US soldiers in Iraq taunting thirsty children with a bottle of water has caused outrage. The footage shows a group of children desperately chasing a truck so they can get a drink. Today the US Department of Defense confirmed the video showed US soldiers and said the images were ‘unfortunate’. The faces of the two men in the vehicle are not revealed but they can be heard saying in American sounding accents: ‘You want some water? Keep running.’

- The London Metro, via here.

In the YouTube age, what will the new, grainy digital images of war do? If smart bomb hits and targeting runs have become sanitized footage for CNN, what about soldiers taunting thirsty Iraqi children, leaving them in the dust? Will we actually react?

Or will we become hollow to these images too?

“That kid’s running forever.”

Fernando Botero, Abu Ghraib 57, 2005. Image © Fernando Botero, courtesy Marlborough Gallery, New York.

Via Slate, where Mia Fineman writes, "Botero, by tackling this imagery in a focused and extended series, has demonstrated not only that such things can be represented in art but also that a figurative, cartoonish idiom may be the most powerful means of representing modern atrocity."

 

"Today, there are echoes of the Vietnam experience in the protracted Iraq war — including a growing protest movement in the military. Its trappings are starkly different this time. Rather than insubordination and violence, it has formed around a form-letter campaign, presumably conducted within the bounds of military regulations that restrict what soldiers are allowed to say. Last week, a group of current troops, with support from a handful of antiwar organizations, announced plans to petition Congress with a collection of "appeals for redress," which call for an immediate withdrawal from Iraq. They had 65 signatures from active-duty troops and reservists."

Via Salon. The photo is the Fort Dix stockade, site of a prisoner rebellion in June 1969, a year after prisoners took over the stockade at Fort Bragg for three days.