“Why I Continue to Believe in the War in Iraq”
by Lynn Chu, via the Writers’ Representatives and just published in Harper’s.
Because to depose a murderous despot is a good thing.
Because the UN resolved to do something a dozen times and didn’t.
Because we are the only nation in the world with the decency and strength to do it.
Because we did so with a minimum of human loss.
Because other nations, rueing their past glory, are envious.
Because I believe in nationbuilding.
Because the left has always insisted on this.
Because I harbor no animus toward Muslim peoples.
Because we must seed the world with democracy, for it is right.
Because Mesopotamia, the cradle of civilization, deserves no less.
Because we destroyed mountains of conventional WMD and averted the sure redevelopment of worse.
Because we halted the UN’s corrupt partnership with tyranny, in the sham of Oil for Food,
Under which the Iraqi people suffered while Saddam and his new business partners sipped oil.
Because containment is impossible in a globalized world.
Because dictators are easier to topple than covert networks.
Because war is best conducted there than on the streets of New York.
Because sanctions were crumbling.
Because in truth the world respects us for it, however they moan.
Because received opinion will change on a dime.
Because Iraqis are an educated people fully capable of democracy,
As is all of humanity.
Because the war and rebuilding can be self-financing with oil.
Because one out of three in the axis of evil is 33.3% better than zero.
Because it makes the left crazy to see the U.S. succeed nobly against a tyrant,
For they love tyranny when it suits them.
Because Saddam financing bin Laden to harry us was only a matter of time.
Because if Saddam had the bomb in 1981, he would soon have it again.
Because a stitch in time saves nine.
Because we needed to finish what we started in 1991.
Because half-measures can be worse than none.
Because America is as brave and competent as it is reasonable to expect of clumsy imperfect humans.
Because in 1948 the UN created Israel, to world acclaim, whose existence is just and must continue to be defended,
For the evil of antisemitism still lurks in the world, in radical Islam and elsewhere.
Because the new kind of war will be sporadic, desultory and covert,
And will bore us, but complacency is dangerous.
Because to them their jihad has only just begun, and crush it we must,
For Osama Bin Laden is not Deng Xiao-Ping.
Because diplomacy is sometimes the path to a solution, but just as often isn’t.
Because our nation is strong enough to shrug off the malice and subversion and sophistries its heedless factions devise.
Who style themselves heroes and whistleblowers.
For their vanity and venality betrays them.
Because this war’s lessons will assist in transformation, which must continue.
For the emasculated CIA and bloated DOD must be reformed.
Because the idea that the world has outgrown war is a fantasy.
Because if we cannot do Iraq then we can never do Rwanda or Darfur.
Because we need to pick our fights.
And there is nothing immoral about making a list ordered by need and self-interest.
For all politics are a balance of factors moral and practical.
Because, when the world is ever really in trouble, fashionable anti-Americanism will fall away.
For all know that America is not the source of evil in the world.
Because people just like to exaggerate
And nowhere is the human condition more on display than in a democracy.
Because all of these considerations are matters for our elected representatives to manage.
Because partisans lie and lose their souls and trick the rest for only a moment.
Because we won in Afghanistan, whose economy is starting to boom.
Because Iraq begs us to stay.
Because the carping elite are hypocrites about all of this, but love to second-guess and criticize.
Because they will do so regardless.
Because the pundits all have other agendas.
Because Iraq must continue to "balance" Iran in that region.
Because we can use a middle east base.
Because avoiding the responsibilities of empire has invoked our enemy and laid the seeds for failed states.
Because failed states harbor criminal gangs.
Because propping up dictators no longer brings "stability."
Because we can no longer countenance killing fields.
Because we must learn how to replace chaos with democracy.
For democracy is both stable and just.
Because civilization is always effortful.
Because we will not and need not suffer a draft to fight the mother of all wars, the very jihad of our enemy’s dreams.
Because this demand shows the critics’ bad faith.
Because their perverse, fervent, secret wish is for another Vietnam.
Because small war is an art, one we need to master.
Because the same will be required of us again, and we must study its statecraft.
Because the UN will save no one.
Because wordsmiths overestimate words.
Because politics is always war by other means.
Because we must expect only carping and ingratitude and have infinite patience.
Because it is the right thing to do and the sophists’ words will vanish with the wind.
Because lies however big, are only temporary.

What???
“Because small war is an art, one we need to master.” And what, exactly, is small about this war? The price tag? Casualty list? Troop deployment? Disastrous impact on our standing in the world?
“Because we can no longer countenance killing fields.”??? We provided the weapons that facilitated those killing fields!
“Because lies, however big, are only temporary.” You have just totally lost me on that one. Explain the fleeting nature of our government’s lies to the families of dead Americans and Iraqis, namely: Iraq definitely has WMD. Saddam tried to buy yellowcake, that’s why we gotta go in! There are strong ties between Saddam and al-Qaeda.
Why does this deserve to be on warpost?
Comment by Gabe Flanders — September 12, 2006 @ 11:28 am
thanks for the outrage. this poem has been up for a while now without comment, or any of my own words. i have to say when i first read it in Harper’s i thought Chu was another Harold Pinter, undermining and exposing war rhetoric with a poetic list of every absurd, simplisitic reason it continues to be supported. i’m thinking of pinter’s poem “American Football (A Reflection upon the Gulf War).” I was sufficiently wrong, it turns out - Chu runs the Writers Representavies LLC, a publising house for Daniel Pipes, Homeland Security chief Michael Chertoff, and a list of others (Newt Gingrich at a time). So I guess Harper’s printed Chu not to show a depressingly sarcastic view of Iraq - a poem made from political recitations - but as the side-work of a conservative publisher. I have to say i still can’t read this poem straight - the constructions are too obvious, i’ve thought it can only be intentionally sarcastic and biting.
but seems not. but it’s on War Post as a document, however appalling it is — even if i continue to think, whatever the writer’s intent, that it can only be read as a literary demonstration in what people will repeat to make themselves believe in war.
Comment by Freddy — September 13, 2006 @ 8:31 am
“Why I Continue to Disbelieve in the War in Iraq”
Because war is a lie.
Because this war is based on a lie, as we all know.
Because people want democracy but not the democracy of G.W. Bush.
Because G.W. Bush is a liar.
Because the President of the United States is a liar.
Because the ‘most powerful man in the world’ is a liar.
Because the president of the USA is a duh (see the thousands of cartoons about him).
Because his pet called Blair is a liar.
Because it is all about oil.
Because he already planned this war before he became president.
Because he loves to dominate.
Because certain people get rich because of this war.
Because his friends get rich because of this war.
Because the friends of his friends…
Because innocent people are being killed.
Because fathers and mothers want their children to have a life.
Because fathers and mothers don’t want their children to die a heroic death.
Because a friend lying dead in a coffin is not what your dear ones want to see.
Because war creates more war.
Because war creates extremism.
Because extremism kills.
Because killing is wrong.
Because being proud of the left leg and a few fingers of your son in a coffin killed in combat doesn’t make sense.
Because killing to make this planet a safer place is a lie.
Because sending soldiers to a second Vietnam is a crime.
Bacause the wounds of Vietnam are still raw.
Because there are still dead soldiers in Vietnam waiting in vain for peace and affection.
Because some will never touch American soil again.
Because many of those killed were literally blasted to pieces by bombing.
Because people are still being killed today in Vietnam by unexploded ordinance, particularly cluster bomblets.
Because the film is on repeat but the title is this time Iraq.
Because of the 2800+ soldiers killed in Iraq.
Because killing your own people is a crime.
Because humiliating people is a crime.
Because revenge is not an option.
Because revenge is no answer.
Because life is more precious than death.
Because those killed were killed because of the lie of the liar of all liars.
Because Nixon was a boyscout compared to Bush.
Because the world has become a more dangerous place.
Because more people will get killed; it might even be you, thanks to a president who believes.
Because the lives of mothers and fathers are destroyed.
Because children are now without a father.
Because a father never had a chance when they sent him there.
Because the mother never had a chance when they sent her there.
Because no matter what they say, we will never run out of tears.
Because we will cry an ocean and we have no ark.
Because people killed by a lie will never return.
Because their tombs will always talk to us.
Because America is not the earth’s police.
Because a soldier returns home and becomes a human being again.
Because there won’t be enough doctors and money to treat all the soldiers with trauma’s.
Because some soldiers will become drug addicts, thieves, murderers because they were told to kill.
Because children will ask us why?
Because we have to tell our children a lie.
Because most people thought the president was right.
Because we found out he is a liar.
Because he killed our children.
Because he destroys families.
Because of him thousands of veterans will commit suicide.
Because more hard drugs are needed to numb the souls of veterans.
Because those who leave in the name of democracy return without a future.
Because no future starts with war.
Because there are already so many war graves.
Because of all the names of those who died so far.
Names of Americans.
Because of the names of those who are still alive at this precise moment in time
but will be dead within ten minutes by a roadside bomb or suicide bomber.
Because there is no one who can say anything positive about this war without feeling a murderer deep inside.
Because we are afraid to dig inside ourselves and see what we are really like, in the name of freedom.
Because soldiers don’t have the freedom to stop killing.
Because they are told to kill.
Because the flag on a coffin doesn’t hide its contents.
Because a flag in a mother’s arms looks ugly.
Because the emptiness eats and eats a bigger hole, never to be filled with alcohol.
Because we could have had grandchildren.
Because there are too many people who understand exactly what it is to lose a child.
Because the pharmaceutiocal industry is rich as it is. 15
Because your war will never bring stability.
Because democracy wants the soldiers out of Iraq, out of other countries.
Because democracy has never been a firing squad.
Because democracy is the majority.
Because Americans want this war to stop, ask CNN.
Because Americans do not want a second Vietnam.
Because Americans do not believe in this president.
Because the president has no respect for the lives of his fellow countrymen.
Because people are tired of the newspaper articles and their photographs with remains.
Because all what remains is a big hole in the ground to be filled with the dead in the name of lies.
Because Americans do not kill children.
Because Americans respect others and their right to lead a normal life.
Because Americans want to be proud again of their country.
Because America is not George Bush.
Comment by J. Bersee — October 26, 2006 @ 12:51 pm
“Because Americans do not kill children.”
What about the nearly 50 million unborn children that great, wonderful, peace-loving, life-loving americans aborted? We’ve killed our own children, and our grandchildren.
“Because fathers and mothers don’t want their children to die a heroic death.”
Then I guess they’d rather have them live as cowards.
Comment by Giselle Brousseau — March 27, 2007 @ 10:39 pm
Yes, Giselle Brousseau , you are right. Americans do kill children, in their own country and in other countries as well. No doubt about it. It is a form of genocide; abortion is killing a nation, the nation of unborn people.
My sentence (“Because fathers and mothers don’t want their children to die a heroic death.”)
simply means that parents want to see their sons and daughters come home alive. And also, refusing to kill doesn’t make you a coward. The soldiers who have had enough and refuse to return are cowards? Soldiers called certain missions ’suicide missions’.
US Army First Lieutenant Ehren Watada says, “I’ve come to believe this is an illegal and an immoral war, and the order to have us deploy to Iraq is unlawful. I won’t follow this order and I won’t participate in something I believe is wrong.”
Comment by J. Bersee — March 29, 2007 @ 6:52 am